In Soap, Cry Baby invites him to come over, and beforehand he takes a bath. While sitting in the bathtub, the tub begins to overflow with water as Cry Baby sings from the outside, describing herself to be unable to find the words to describe her feelings about him. The television in the bathroom turns on, displaying clips from the promotional video. When the line "threw a toaster in the bathtub" is sung, a toaster is dropped into the tub, electrocuting Johnny. Then, bubbles begin to appear, with Johnny popping them. Cry Baby then appears in the bathtub, kissing Johnny soon after.
In Training Wheels, Cry Baby sings about her transitioning relationship with Johnny, wanting to move to the next stage. She teaches him how to ride a bike without training wheels which symbolizes their changing stages, and they hang around for a bit in alternating scenes. When he is able to successfully ride the bike, he rides towards her. Cry Baby, falling in love, leans in for a kiss, but Johnny disappears. This symbolizes that although she was ready for their relationship to move on, Johnny was not.
He later breaks her heart when he didn't show up for her birthday party in Pity Party, as his name appears on one of the invitations.
Although his character has not been expanded on much, Johnny was notably more compassionate towards Cry Baby than her previous boyfriend, Alphabet Boy. However, he proved to be someone who had feared commitment, as shown in his absence at Cry Baby's birthday party and hesitation to move forward in their relationship.
- Johnny is based on the boy referenced in Lesley Gore's 1963 song It's My Party.
- The song Pity Party is based on and samples the same song.
|Featured Tracks||Cry Baby • Dollhouse • Sippy Cup • Carousel • Alphabet Boy • Soap • Training Wheels • Pity Party • Tag, You're It • Milk and Cookies • Pacify Her • Mrs. Potato Head • Mad Hatter|
|Bonus Tracks||Play Date • Teddy Bear • Cake|
|Characters||Cry Baby • Johnny • Alphabet Boy • Big Bad Wolf • Mom • Dad • Brother • Beth Anne • Mistress • Cashier • Basic Bitch • Blue Boy • Bunny Doctor • Mrs. Potato Head • Mr. Potato Head • Nurse • Rushton Dolls|
|Extras||Digital Booklet • Removed Songs • Merchandise|
|Locations||Cry Baby's House • Big Bad Wolf's House • Grocery Store • Carnival • Hospital|