After the events of "Pity Party", the Big Bad Wolf notices that Cry Baby is now single and stalks her in an ice cream truck to lure her into his trap. He gives her a cone of ice cream that causes her to pass out then kidnaps her and takes her to his home. In "Milk and Cookies", he orders Cry Baby to make milk and cookies for him. She adds poison to the cookies, resulting in his death.
|Featured Tracks||Cry Baby • Dollhouse • Sippy Cup • Carousel • Alphabet Boy • Soap • Training Wheels • Pity Party • Tag, You're It • Milk and Cookies • Pacify Her • Mrs. Potato Head • Mad Hatter|
|Bonus Tracks||Play Date • Teddy Bear • Cake|
|Characters||Cry Baby • Johnny • Alphabet Boy • Big Bad Wolf • Mom • Dad • Brother • Little Girl • Beth Anne • Mistress • Cashier • Basic Bitch • Blue Boy • Bunny Doctors • Mrs. Potato Head • Mr. Potato Head • Nurse • Rushton Dolls|
|Extras||Digital Booklet • Removed Songs • Merchandise|
|Locations||Cry Baby's House • Big Bad Wolf's House • Grocery Store • Carnival • Hospital|