I’m not fully informed on the matter, but it’s possible that Timothy might be lying, given her questionable history (I haven’t confirmed this since the screenshots I’ve seen might be false). It’s also possible that Melanie could be at fault, although we don’t have certainty, as only they know the absolute truth. One concerning thing is that Melanie said, “she never said no to what we decided to do together,” which suggests a lack of understanding about consent, or at least that’s how it appeared. She might have just misspoken, but we can’t be sure. It’s best to wait for Melanie to make a statement, although she might choose not to.