Milk and Cookies

The milk got expired and the cookies were overcooked

Rules:

Don't start any arguments or Drama

One comment only per post

Remaining:

Dollhouse

Carousel

Soap

Pity Party

Tag, You're It

Mrs. Potato Head

Mad Hatter

Pings: @EE1And 2 @JuztZiek

La, la, la, la... la, la, la, la...

Finished! | can you guess what I'll do next?

Almost finished! (sorry for the watermark looking like that, I got the time limit on ibisPaint reached)

What if Dead to me is about the bad wolf ice cream man? I think this because in Dead to Me Melanie talks about burying him underground and in Milk and Cookies, he locks Crybaby underground. Also, Melanie stated that Milk and Cookies is “like a weird sequel” to Dead to Me

Before you ask, “Is this Melanie Martinez related?” The whole inspirational playlist of songs are ALL by Melanie Martinez! I’m writing a fanfic called “Yellow and Gray” where it’s basically a double fanfic where Lawrie finally gets help for his eating disorder, and Belle and Sam get Hanahaki over each other. Link below!

https://docs.google.com/document/d/18zYQC2ySczy0y1KqzBXS5ncE4ZefIjZnxZaS6xNx8es/edit

Idk why but Milk and Cookies beat and Unhappy Meal’s sounds a little bit similar to me especially the outro

(Edit)

Nope it’s not similar

Ugh that fact im 14 and been listening for 7 years amazes me

Soap and Training Wheels had a double feature music video, same with Tag, You're It and Milk and Cookies. But the order of the songs are Soap, Training Wheels, Pity Party, Tag, You're It, Milk and Cookies and the other songs.

We all know Johnny and Cry Baby are the characters in Soap/Training Wheels music video. And at the start of the Pity Party music video, Cry Baby was writing invites for her friends, one of them being Johnny, we all know what happened at the same music video, alright. At the start of the Tag, You're It/Milk and Cookies music video, Cry Baby is seeing throwing party decorations in the trash, but what happened in the last song? Yeah... So Soap, Training Wheels, Pity Party, Tag, You're It and Milk and Cookies are connected to one another

So I made a fanmade milk and cookies demo

https://youtu.be/Ihy0gdHQOkE

IK this is random but I'm just curious lmao

So we know that milk and cookies was originally about cry baby poisoning her bf, Johnny is mentioned in jump rope, jump rope was replaced by tag you’re it, so my theory is that in the original version of cry baby, Johnny was meant to be poisoned

I’m I the only in who sees tag you’re it as a prequel to a million men, and milk and cookies as a sequel? To me it just kinda fits